Saturday, December 14, 2013

Critical Thinking Reading Response on What Happened to Goodbye

Critical thinking question: How does this text address the points of view of other groups, especially who usually don't get to tell their sides of the story? 

In "What Happened to Goodbye" by Sarah Dessen they show a side of a divorce that isn't regularly heard at the time that is being explained. When Mclean's parents divorced 3 years before the time that the story is set it was strange, sudden and extremely tough on the family. Divorce has such a big effect on everyone in a family and all books seem to focus on is the parents but this book focuses on the child (teen) and how it is still affecting her 3 years after. The examples that support this is that Mclean is in complete narrative of her point of view of the divorce and just her, Mclean in this is telling her view of not only how she felt when it happened but how she feels after the divorce. This is why in the book you get a reference of Mclean's point of view and her perspectives of the divorce.
"What Happened to Goodbye" gives a peek into a different perspective because it's in Mclean's point of view and we're getting a look at how it affected her and just her as the kid. Normally you only get to see how it affected a family as a whole but in this book you really get to see how the kid feels afterwards and how her life has changed and is still changing. For example, in the book Mclean states that she is sick of her mom putting herself first and doesn't want anything to change custody wise, this gives people a peek into what kids would say/do if they really had a say in divorce. We really see that even though divorce may bring up sensitive and big issues with the 2 spouses against each other, it brings up issues against the parents from the kid. This is one example of seeing a different point of view in the book.
Another way that the book shows Mclean's perspective is that she's not only telling us about how she felt when it was happening but also afterwards and how it is still affecting her. The book is set 3 years after the divorce and now Mclean has gone from living with her mom and dad in the same place for her whole life to moving around with her dad every year. Within this we see how she has taken to making friends, settling in and even who she decides to be in each different place. When she explains what she's going through, it's all about her life and how she decides to adapt, which is a really rare thing as usually we only really get to see how kids are coping with the divorces as it's happening, and most of their time we don't get any idea of  their view on it. This is another way that Mclean shows an unusual perspective of a situation.
In conclusion, Mclean shows a different point of view because we get to see how she adjusts rather than her parents and we also get to see how her life changes after the divorce. This is a perspective we don't usually get to take a look at and a group that doesn't usually have much of a voice. This is how and why "What Happened to Goodbye" by Sarah Dessen shows a point of view from a group that don't usually get to tell their side.  

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Critical Thinking Question Reading Response

 Critical Thinking Question: At what points do you feel yourself resisting from the book, characters or authors? What does your resistance say about the book, and what does it say about you?

        When reading books, it's easy to figure out what's right and wrong in what's happening to the character. In the book What Happened to Goodbye by Sarah Dessen I feel resistance towards Mcleans situation. There are many points on the book where the flippancy of which McLean talks about her life situation makes me feel awkward, sorry, a little disturbed yet grateful all at the same time. Mclean's mom walked out on Mclean's dad for his famous basketball idol and with that Mclean moved in with her dad. After, she's a complete different person and it has changed not only her, but Mclean's life completely.
Mclean Sweet has been switching the town in which she lives in almost yearly since her mom walked out on her and her dad and with the moves, she changes her name and personality with it. She has been Eliza, Lizbet, Beth, and finally just Mclean again. With the names she changed from popular, to drama geek then to the yearbook-school president-school absorbed girl. Every time she mentioned these changes I felt myself holding back, resisting, towards the book. It's the fact that she took it as normal and felt strange that people referred to her as her real name that I started to feel sorry for her. On pages 6-7 Mclean is explaining all of her name changes and personalities and how it just came to her, that it was normal and I started to feel so bad that she never got to be herself and that she took this as such a normal thing. I felt myself feeling strangely about it and feeling really bad for her that she didn't even know who she really is anymore all because of her mom being rude and not thinking about Mclean and her dad. This is one thing in What Happened to Goodbye that made me resist from the book.
When Mclean's mom and dad divorced it wasn't the normal "we're unhappy" situation. Since college, Mclean's dad's beloved basketball team was Defriese. So now, after being happily married and changing from the spoiled child she was, Mclean's mom had an affair with the Defriese coach and left Mclean and her father for him. As if this isn't a weird enough, sad enough and big enough change, Mclean's dad got a new job from the restaurant that him and his ex-wife owned together, that requires him to fix up restaurants that need help, this means that Mclean gets to spend one year at a place then has to move. Mclean goes from having the near to perfect, happy family in the place she lived in her whole life to having her mom being heartless and never being able to settle down. This is one big thing that makes me resist from the book. It's such a strange and sad situation and although Mclean cares about it and is sour towards her mom because of it, she doesn't act up or talk about it. She treats it as a normal divorce and although that's better than rebelling, it's so extreme and makes me feel slightly uncomfortable. It's a terrible thing to happen and the flippancy being used to describe it is a little too weird. This is another thing that makes me resist from the book.
A final thing in What Happened to a Goodbye that bought resistance was when I understood just how much Mclean's mom really had changed. On page 172 Mclean describes her mom as she was as a rich teenager, as her dad's wife and as she is now and I began to see that she went from a popular rich girl dating a congress mans son, to Katie Sweet who had a messy pony tail and her appearance was last priority and then to Katherine Hamilton, the rich basketball coaches wife who had a horrific scandal but was then the high class, high maintenance mother of twins. When she was Katie Sweet she was a family woman who ran the family business and always put her husband and daughter first where as she then decided to heartlessly leave her husband in an instant and try to take his daughter too, this completely changed her to the point where money is priority and although she tries for her daughter, she has forgotten about how they used to be, including their tradition of going to a low class motel just because they love the spot on the beach and has completely disowned who she used to be. This is a final thing that for me, bought resistance to the book.
What Happened to Goodbye brought up many spots of resistance. This was caused by Mclean's personality changes during her yearly moves, when Mclean states how she her mum walked out on her and her dad, and finally when the changes of Mclean's mom after leaving her dad are described. This shows how tough Mclean's situation is and these are just a few of the situations that she is in that portray the resistance while reading. This is why I felt resistance from Sarah Dessen's What Happened to Goodbye.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Argument Essay 2nd draft

Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is an in depth, complicated book with mature content and language that can easily be questioned. Therefore, it should be taken of libraries for children under the age of 13. This book has very mature language for kids who may not understand the context in which they're using it as it relates back to the time period with language that is now questioned. This is one reason why it should be banned or cautioned for kids under 13. It also has quite a lot of graphic violence. Of Mice and Men is a book about two slightly troubled men so they run into situations leading up to fights, and Steinbeck described them with a lot of depth which got overwhelming at times. Some people might say that kids should decide if they're ready to read this themselves, but they might not know what's included, and by banning for under 13 we can somewhat guarantee that they're not being exposed before they're really ready. This is why Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck should be banned or cautioned for under 13.
The first example of why Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is because there's a lot of very mature language that many children won't understand while being used in context. Not only is this language inappropriate, but it also is hurtful in the present and could be not understood why or how it's being used if they didn't understand it. One example in the book of this is when Curley says: "Where the hell is that god damn n______?" To stable buck, a black (29). This shows bad language offensively and could easily upset people if they didn't understand the time period and segregation in that time. Another example of mature language is when Curley's wife uses "w___e house" (79) as a term. In those times there was more sexualism and kids need to understand that there was issues with this and that they have been fixed, it could possibly encourage them to use offensive terms towards women and by banning for kids under 13, before they understand the time period, we can make sure that kids don't use offensive terms and think it's ok. The Banned Books We Have Loved talks about how bad language is appearing in so many books and how parents and teachers are banning because of it. There are also terms in the book that may not be overly offensive, but aren't for kids to be using. The final example of mature language is when George says, "if that crazy bastard is messing around too much just kick him out, Slim" (50) referring to Lennie playing with the puppies. Kids need to be able to understand these topics and kids under 13 may not be able to. Therefore we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13.
        Another reason why we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13 is because there's a lot of graphic violence. One example of this is when Steinbeck is describing the fight between Curley and Lennie. They describe with so much detail that it could easily freak people put or even encourage them to start fights themselves. It describes the fight by saying, "But Lennie watched in terror at the flopping man whom he held. Blood ran down Lennie's face. One of his eyes was cut and closed." It described the harm so in detail that younger kids may either not feel comfortable or feel encouraged. The article Darkness too visible goes against The Hunger a Games by Suzanne Collins for its violence in content and the fact that it could encourage children, although not so extreme, the same message goes for Of Mice and Men. Finally, an example of graphic violence is when Lennie accidentally kills Curley's wife. It describes this by saying "'Don't you go yellin' , he said, and he shook her; her body flipped like a fish and then she was still, for Lennie had broken her neck'" (91). Although this was an accidental murder it could make people uncomfortable to read and have described. The violence in this book may be harmless to many but it's that small amount of people that will take it to heart and use it in their own life and up until 13 you can't completely guarantee the maturity needed to control themselves. This is another reason why we should ban Of Mice and Men for children under the age of 13.
        On the other hand of this argument, people may say that kids should be able to decide themselves if they're ready to read this book, however, they might not completely know if they're mature enough before they read it. Kids may think they're ready to read certain books and they may feel strongly that they should be able to decide but if there's no one telling them what's in the book and if they're ready, then they're exposed. Kids might be mature enough not to take the information to heart, but they should really understand classics when they're reading them and it's in 7th grade when you learn about segregation and why we don't use it any more, kids should understand features of Americas Great Depression (when the book is focused). We should be able to somewhat guarantee that kids aren't being exposed to books too early, especially classics, and by banning for under 13 we can help make a start on that. Therefore, even though kids may want to control what they are reading, they may be over exposed and this is why we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13.
        All in all, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck should be banned for kids under the age of 13 because it contains mature language, graphic violence, and even though kids feel that they should make their own decisions when it comes to what they read, they may not be mature enough to read this book until they learn about Great Depression America, around the age of 13. Of Mice and Men should be banned it challenged for under 13 and these examples show why.

Saturday, November 16, 2013

Monday Muse Post

        I have recently been listening to one of Justin Bieber's first albums (My World 2.0). Although it was originally because I had to keep waiting for more music, it has now bought me back faith in Justin. Recently his stories have been anything but promising for his fans but listening to this music made me realize that yes, he has changed lately, but it's just him growing up. If we all had cameras on us throughout our lives we probably wouldn't seem like the greatest people either.
        There are things in this album that make him sound like an egotistical teenager, such as Kiss and Tell and Eenie Meenie, and they're still great songs, what can you expect from a teen pop star? You can also hear songs where it seems like he's a true down to earth person, such as Overboard and Never Let You Go and this is what no one seems to notice. I went to the Believe tour twice and I did see a change, he was an hour late to the second but who knows his actual story? The media is only going to focus on the bad for publicity reasons and lately I've had nothing else to believe but these stories. Listening to this album, although not a real importance, has inspired me to bring back faith in Justin and not to just believe he stories I'm reading in the media but to believe that he is still really the same person he was at 13 and he's only growing up.

Monday, November 11, 2013

Argument Essay Draft

        Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is an in depth, complicated book, therefore, it should be cautioned for children under the age of 13. This book has very mature language for kids who may not understand the context in which they're using it. This is one reason why it should be banned or cautioned for kids under 13. Another example is because it has quite a lot of graphic violence. Of Mice and Men is a book about two challenged and slightly troubled men so they run into situations leading up to fights, and Steinbeck described them with a lot if depth which got very overwhelming at times. Some people might say that kids should decide if they're ready to read this themselves but they might not know what's included, and by banning from under 13 we can somewhat guarantee that they're not being exposed before they're really ready. This is the final reason why Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck should be banned or cautioned for under 13.
The first example of why Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is because there's a lot of very mature language that many children won't understand while being used in context. Not only is this language inappropriate, but it also is hurtful in the present and could be not understood why or how it's being used if they didn't understand it. One example in the book of this is when Curley says "Where the h____ is that god d____ n______?" To stable buck, a black on page 29. This shows bad language offensively and could easily upset people if they didn't understand the time period and segregation in that time. Another example of mature language is on page 79 when Curley's wife uses "w___e house" as a term. In those times there was more sexualism and kids need to understand that there was issues with this and that they have been fixed, it could possibly encourage them to use offensive terms towards women and by banning for kids under 13, before they understand the time period, we can make sure that kids don't use offensive terms and think it's ok. There are also terms in the book that may not be overly offensive, but aren't for kids to be using. The final example of mature language, one that should just not be used by children, is in page 50 when George says "if that crazy b_____d is messing around too much just kick him out, Slim" referring it Lennie playing with the puppies. Kids need to be able to understand these topics and kids under 13 may not be able to. Therefore we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13.
Another reason why we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13 is because there's a lot of graphic violence. One example of this is when Steinbeck is describing the fight between Curley and Lennie. They describe with so much detail that it could easily freak people put or even encourage them to start fights themselves. It describes the fight by saying "But Lennie watched in terror at the flopping man whom he held. Blood ran down Lennie's face. One of his eyes was cut and closed." It described the harm so in detail that younger kids may either not feel comfortable or feel encouraged. Finally, an example of graphic violence is when Lennie accidentally kills Curley's wife. On page 91 it describes this by saying " 'don't you go yellin' , he said, and he shook her; her body flipped like a fish and then she was still, for Lennie had broken her neck'". Although this was an accidental murder it could make people uncomfortable to read and have described. The violence in this book may be harmless to many but it's that small amount of people that will take it to heart and use it in their own life and up until 13 you can't completely guarantee the maturity needed to control themselves. This is another reason why we should ban Of Mice and Men for children under the age of 13.
On the other hand of this argument, people may say that kids should be able to decide themselves if they're ready to read this book, however, they might not completely know if they're mature enough before they read it. Kids may think they're ready to read certain books and they may feel strongly that they should be able to decide but if there's no one telling them what's in the book and if they're ready, then they're exposed. Kids might be mature enough not to take the information to heart, but they should really understand classics when they're reading them and it's in 7th grade when you learn about segregation and why we don't use it any more, kids should understand features of Americas Great Depression (when the book is focused). We should be able to somewhat guarantee that kids aren't being exposed to books too early, especially classics, and by banning for under 13 we can help make a start on that. Therefore, even though kids may want to control what they are reading, they may be over exposed and this is why we should ban Of Mice and Men for kids under 13.
All in all, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck should be banned for kids under the age of 13 because it contains mature language, graphic violence, and even though kids feel that they should make their own decisions when it comes to what they read, they may not be mature enough to read this book until they learn about Great Depression America, around the age of 13. Of Mice and Men should be banned it challenged for under 13 and these examples show why.

Saturday, October 26, 2013

Monday Muses Post

My Childhood
        My childhood was complicated, joyful, confusing and so many other things, yet I remember every detail of it. When I was younger my family consisted of my Dads side and my Moms side. I have two siblings Paige and Jake who are both older, that I lived with for quite a while but now we're all separate. I had so many different times, homes and experiences with both sides of my huge confusing family. I've always been close to my Aunts, Uncles and cousins as well as my two grandmas so my family got big and confusing at times. Although it may sound complicated it all tied together and my childhood was all based off of those different family sides and the people within them. Until I was nearly 8 years old I lived in Nottingham, England (which is where my family still is). It's a pretty uneventful place but after a lifetime there, you learn to make your own exciting experiences. 
        My parents are separated so I got the weekdays with my dad and weekends with my mom. I went to school, came home, went to friends houses, the usual uneventful life things. But my family and friends made it a little more lively. I have so many examples of this after 8 years if experiencing it. Even my school life was made exciting, I hardly remember ever learning. My school memories mainly consist of writing a letter to J.K. Rowling (she responded and even though I wasn't a fan of Harry Potter it was an exciting moment for a seven year old who could hardly write), making a sandwich creation with friends for a health providing project, which was surprisingly tasty, singing HELP by The Beatles for Red Nose Day (a charity day in England) and my school having surprisingly good school lunches. That was my school life. It was good because you had 3 recesses so you never felt like you had work. My friends played a big role in making my life a little more exciting. I remember having my friend Ewan's really nice mom look after me after school as she was friends with my grandma (she seemed to know everyone), giving me really good food and being crazy upset when she was diagnosed with cancer. I remember my friends Jasmine, Emilia, Molly and Nicole who were my friends for practically my whole life and I remember leaving them and my school behind when I moved, I remember when I was about to move My whole class (which was practically the whole grade) made me a big card behind my back during lunch and I stupidly wandered into the classroom while they were making it because I was looking for my friends, I still have that card. These are examples of my friends making my life a little more lively. 
        I have a confusing but hilarious family on both sides. I am unlike everyone in the fact that I can actually stay somewhat quiet for more than 30 seconds. My family is animate, clumsy and funny all at the same time (but everyone gets really moody at times). I'll start with my sister, her name is Paige. Paige and I were really close when I was younger and she's one of the people I miss most (she still lives in England with my mom). She's 19 now and even though she's grown up a lot she still acts like a 7 year old. I always have the memory in my head of my moms way too big house and us trying to watch a movie then the electric going out. She went to fix it but she took way too long so I started panicking. I didn't want to get up because I was scared and when I finally got the courage to look...I found her texting on the kitchen. I always remember Paige being so happy and nice to me and then getting mad if I said one thing. She still does that, so you can see how much she didn't mature. Next is my mom (mum). I miss my mom but she did so many things that annoyed me when I was in England that it's hard to forget about them, I can still be a moody teenager towards my mom even if she is 3,000 miles away. When I was 6 years old she promised me that she'd take me to a water park on my birthday. So I was all ready to go, I had my new Nintendo, all 7 of us piled into the 5 person car, we started driving all talking about how excited we were, and then my mom got us lost. I was so frustrated. I had her asking everyone for directions but she got so annoyed after 3 1/2 hours that we ended up turning back and going to our regular pool for 1/2 and hour. I was so angry. Next is my brother, Jake. I have a lot of memories of him even though the time we spent together was limited and when I was younger. I remember him, Paige and my cousin Jade all tying me to an office chair with a scarf and spinning me around until I thought I would throw up. I remember him coming to me on my 5th birthday at my grandmas house and giving me a coloring book and that being the last time for 7 years seeing him. I saw him this summer for the first time since then and it was like nothing even happened. Even though I was tiny when this was happening I always remember him being crazy protective over me when I was a baby because I was the new youngest and he was the "responsible older brother" (even though he was only 4 at the time). That was my moms side and little parts of my family on that side.
        Now my Dad's side. My Dad has always been my closest parent and family member. I have too many memories to even remember because I've been constantly with him and living with for 13 years now. Although I do have one memory, him taking me to High School Musical on ice at 6 years old and letting me stay up until 10:00. It was a pretty big moment for me at that age. I was always close to my grandma (Nana). She passed away when I was 6 but I practically lived with her until then. She tended to every need as I was "the daughter she always wanted after 6 sons". She always wanted the best for me, she bought the special apple juice I loved, took me to places, defended me when my dad got frustrated (even though it was always my fault anyway) and put me first in everything. When she had her 2nd stroke it was in Butlins, a holiday resort that we went to with my Uncle Terry and Cousins Adam and Callum while my dad was in Berlin. We had just arrived and she started forgetting everyone's names, even my uncles who was her own son. I was sobbing and she couldn't understand why yet while she was forgetting everything, she never forgot my name. As for her 3rd and final stroke it was just before picking me up from school, and I'll never forget being panicked when my dad came early picking me up instead because it had tragically killed her. I didn't cry because I was so grateful that I had made he most of my time with her, she was my second mother. Now for my uncle Billy. He and I are and always have been extremely close. He has always looked after me and is there for me. He has 3 kids, George, Ava and Beck who are hilarious and completely out of their minds. George is 4 years younger than me, Ava is 7 years younger and Beck is almost 2. My uncle looked after me a lot when I was younger and always took me swimming. I remember this one time when he took me swimming at nearly 4 years old, before I could swim, and he took off my floaties. He looked at me and said "I'm going for a quick swim stay here and swim around"  (because I could swim with floaties on) so he left me and completely forgot I was without them. He ducked under water to start swimming and when he got up and looked over at me after a few minutes I was half under water gargling and trying to stick my head up as he rushed over, I was absolutely fine but now it's funny to remind him whenever I visit. I miss my uncle and cousins probably most out of everyone in England and I wish they would come and visit New York more. This is my Dad's side of the family. 
       Before I moved to NY with my dad to live with my stepmom, Vik, I only visited once. I loved it as my dad knew I would, and it didn't matter to me about moving after that because I knew I would be much better off. The majority of my memories have been in England because most of my life was there and my life stayed pretty much the same after I moved here (which I'm happy about), except for a new sister, Freja (freya) who is nearly 3, my life has been consistent. I have a lot of the same friends from elementary school, I live in the same neighborhood and I have the same home life that I have had since 3rd grade. My childhood may have been complicated and confusing but it was exciting and it determined my life and the person that I am now. 

Saturday, October 12, 2013

"The Future of Us" Theme Reading Response

In the book "The Future of Us" by Jay Asher and Caroline Mackler there are a few themes. One of the themes is that you can't change what's meant to happen. In the book the two best friends, Josh and Emma discover Facebook on a CD-ROM in 1996, before Facebook was even invented and they can see their futures 15 years into the future. Josh and Emma have been friends forever but grew apart after Josh developed feelings for Emma. Facebook brings them closer together but when they see their lives, which may or may not be what they want, they tweak things in the present, causing "ripples" in time. They don't know how big the changes may be but let's just say every time they click back things have changed. I think one example that shows that you can't change what's meant to happen is a theme in the book is when Emma try's to change little things it effects her future. Another example is when Emma and Josh get into a fight and it changes their friendship for life. These are examples why the theme in the book is that you can't change what's meant to happen.
 
        One example in the book that shows that you can't change what's meant to happen is when Emma try's to change things in the present, it effects her future. You see this in the book in many ways. One example in the book that shows this is that when she rips up the picture from GoodTimez pizza with her friends, she does it because she's mad and she knows she puts it on Facebook, so then in the future you can see that there's lines where she taped it back up. Although this is small you later see that it happened in the past. This is one example of how you can't change what's meant to happen. Another example that shows how things that Emma changes in life affects her future is calling Jordan Jones Jr. Jordan was meant to be her husband but when she reads that she isn't happy as his wife she figures out a way to stop from marrying him. She calls him from present day and pretends that they talked at a party then she crosses Tampa State-where he attends and they meet-off of her college list. Not only did Emma affect her future love life, kids, possible job from college education and future home town but she may have just changed it to someone bad, luckily she did not that time but you can see how it affected the future and yet she kept meddling, she changes her home, her husband twice more and her kids. This shows how the present effects the future and how you can't change what's meant to happen.
 
Another thing that shows how the theme of the book is that you can't change what's meant to happen is when Josh and Emma get into a fight. When Emma try's to show Josh how things in the present cause ripples in their future, it turns it into a stupid and dangerous game Josh gets angry and tells yew to stop. Then she keeps going and goes further. Josh just sits there telling her she's making a mistake until she goes one step too far and kisses Josh. Josh gets angry as a year before he kissed her and she stormed away making things awkward for a long time. He says some very offensive things to Emma and she gets angry, but tries to claim that she likes him. Josh doesn't believe her but actually changes his own future by dating his future wife. This makes Emma jealous and they get into a fight. When Emma checks Facebook and looks under her friends she sees no Josh. She then notices that if she doesn't apologize then they may never be friends again and although she knows this it takes her a long time to find the guts to actually apologize, Josh wants to do the same. This argument shows that you can't change what's meant to happen. 
 
This shows why and how the theme in "The Future of Us" by Jay Asher and Caroline Mackler is that you can't change what's meant to happen. Josh and Emma explain this well as they meddle with their future and end up regretting it and not really knowing what will end up happening. Examples of this are, that changing things in the present will affect the future, and Emma and Josh's fight that causes them not to be friends in the future, until they apologize. This is why I think the theme if this interesting book is that you can't change what's meant to happen.